Archive notice: This article was originally published on July 29, 2008. Links and embedded videos are preserved as part of the historical record.
In early July 2008, the Munich Higher Regional Court (OLG, case no. 6 U 2759/07) issued a final decision in the legal dispute between Oracle and usedSoft concerning trade in used licenses. In its now-available written reasons, the court states that distributing used software generally requires the respective rights holder’s consent.
The court’s Sixth Civil Senate, which specializes in copyright law, makes clear that this applies not only to software originally placed on the market by download, as in the case heard, but also to trading used original data carriers. This final decision corresponds to Microsoft’s legal view that buying and selling reproduction rights from Microsoft volume-license agreements without the company’s consent is ineffective and therefore infringes copyright. Microsoft consequently sees the judgment as having far-reaching effects on the entire used-software trade and its customers.
In its reasoning, the court states that balancing Oracle’s intellectual-property rights against the right freely to choose and practice an occupation does not produce a different result. A software manufacturer’s copyrighted usage rights require particular protection because they are especially vulnerable, and copyright law accounts for this. The court therefore said usedSoft had no overriding right “to establish a business operation that explicitly intends to interfere with third-party copyrights.”
Microsoft regards the judgment as settling the used-software debate in favor of software manufacturers. “The judgment finally creates clarity,” explains Dorothee Belz, Director of Law & Corporate Affairs and member of Microsoft Deutschland GmbH’s management team. “The decision confirms our view that rights holders themselves may decide whether usage rights to their software can be relicensed.” The court rejected usedSoft’s applications for referral to the European Court of Justice and permission to appeal to the Federal Court of Justice on the grounds that the legal position was clear and unambiguous. However, usedSoft may appeal the refusal to permit a further appeal.
$$$$
Critical situation for users of used software
The judgment particularly affects users who deploy or are currently purchasing used Microsoft volume licenses. They must be aware of the considerable legal risk arising from possible incorrect licensing. Every user should therefore examine the applicable transfer rules carefully. Microsoft expressly reserves the right to take legal action in future against dealers in used software and, where appropriate, their customers who violate those rules.
Background to the decision
In a judgment issued on March 15, 2007 (case no. 7 O 7061/06), Munich Regional Court I prohibited Munich used-software dealer HHS usedSoft GmbH from offering used Oracle licenses to third parties and thereby inducing them to use Oracle software. The simple, non-transferable usage rights granted by Oracle constituted a permissible restriction on onward transfer with proprietary effect. In addition, the rights holder’s consent to use of the software by a second purchaser was required under Section 34 of the German Copyright Act.
In its decision announced on July 3, 2008 (6 U 2759/07), the Munich Higher Regional Court upheld the lower court judgment and referred fully to the reasons already given by the Regional Court. It added that the prohibition also covers distributing usage rights together with an original data carrier. This contradicted a recent decision by a single Munich judge dated November 28, 2007 (case no. 30 O 8684/07), which had considered transfer of “used” Microsoft licenses permissible provided that at least one original data carrier was also transferred. The Higher Regional Court decision also makes clear that the already prohibited claim that notarial certificates alone establish the legality of purchasing used software is incorrect.
Further Links:
- More information
