Archive notice: This article was originally published on August 12, 2008. Links and embedded videos are preserved as part of the historical record.
teil of the Munich Higher Regional Court in the legal dispute between Oracle and usedSoft, a transfer expressly requires the «permission of the holder of the usage rights» (case no. 6 U 2759/07).
«To take action against trade in used software licences that violates copyright, we initiated numerous test purchases and spoke with users of such licences. In doing so, we discovered identical product keys among different users. However, since Microsoft did not consent to a transfer of used licences to these companies, in our view these licences have not been validly transferred and the companies are not lawfully licensed. Companies are often unaware that copyright infringements can, for example, result in claims for damages and injunctive relief by the manufacturer. By blocking the product keys, we are now sending a clear signal and restricting the use of this software», explains Dorothee Belz, Director Law and Corporate Affairs and a member of the management board of Microsoft Deutschland GmbH.
Munich Higher Regional Court Prohibits Trade in Used Software Licences
According to the current ruling in the legal dispute between Oracle and usedSoft, the transfer of contractual usage rights expressly requires the «permission of the holder of the usage rights». Furthermore, usedSoft has no overriding right «to open a business that explicitly intends to infringe third-party copyrights», the court stated in its reasoning. A software manufacturer’s copyright usage rights require particular protection because of their particular vulnerability. Without the software manufacturers’ express consent, the onward transfer of software licences and the handing over of the product key to third parties is therefore unlawful in our view.
Which Licences Are Legal, Which Are Illegal?
Trade in used licences that are part of a volume licensing agreement, such as those large companies conclude with software manufacturers, is problematic. If the contract states that the software licence may only be transferred with the manufacturer’s consent and this consent is not obtained, the buyer of the used licence does not acquire valid usage rights and may therefore not be properly licensed. However, counterfeit data carriers, fake manuals, certificates of authenticity and licence certificates not issued by the software manufacturer are also in circulation.
«Ignorance is no defence. In cases of doubt, the software users must prove that they hold a lawful licence. When acquiring a used licence, this means they must document to whom Microsoft originally issued the licence and how and through whom it was subsequently transferred to the new user. Self-printed licence certificates or notarial confirmations do not promise legal certainty. They are not legally valid proof of a licence», Belz stresses.
Microsoft Offers a Service to Check the Authenticity of Licences
The free Microsoft Product Identification Service (PID Service for short) assists specialist dealers and end customers in Germany: suspicious products sent to Microsoft with a request for identification are checked for authenticity. Since the service started in 1999, Microsoft in Germany has checked more than 220,000 submitted and confiscated products for authenticity. The proportion of illegal products in these evaluations is 96 percent. As a rule, the sender receives information about authenticity within 24 hours of the unaltered product arriving at Microsoft.
