Microsoft Intimidates Customers

Microsoft announced today that “product keys flagged as suspicious” had been blocked. The fact is, however: Microsoft’s sales model does not rule out the same product key being issued to up to hundreds of customers simultaneously, for example through major distributors.

Archive notice: This article was originally published on August 19, 2008. Links and embedded videos are preserved as part of the historical record.

The fact that identical product keys are used by different customers at the same time is therefore by no means certain evidence of unlawful use, but part of Microsoft’s sales model. “This announcement is the software monopolist’s shameless attempt to intimidate software users by distorting the facts,” explains usedSoft managing director Peter Schneider.

Microsoft had already blocked a small number of product keys in June 2008 because they had fallen into the hands of fraudsters. Today’s Microsoft announcement presumably refers to precisely this case, which happened some time ago. This may be Microsoft’s attempt to present an old case as current in order to connect it with the Munich Higher Regional Court’s Oracle ruling, which came only afterwards.

Microsoft’s reference in this context to the Munich Higher Regional Court’s recent Oracle ruling is easily seen-through propaganda. After all, the Munich Regional Court only recently issued a final ruling “that the sale or disposal of individual Microsoft software licences previously issued under volume licensing agreements is, in principle, also validly possible without Microsoft’s consent.” The Munich Higher Regional Court’s ruling, which is not final, by contrast applies only to Oracle software. In its Microsoft ruling, the Munich Regional Court recently pointed out that the two cases (Oracle and Microsoft software) were not comparable.

The background: because identical Microsoft product keys are issued to so many companies and individuals, it naturally happens occasionally that these keys are misused by fraudsters. When Microsoft learns of this, all Microsoft customers with that product key receive a warning, for example when downloading an update from the Microsoft server.

This can now also happen to usedSoft customers because the product key they share with many other Microsoft customers fell into the wrong hands through other users. But this does not mean that the usedSoft customers therefore acquired their licences unlawfully. They can of course continue using this software with peace of mind if they bought it from a reputable used-software dealer such as usedSoft.

Incidentally, in 2006 Microsoft used the same argument (product keys appearing multiple times) in an attempt to criminalise usedSoft as a software pirate. The Munich Public Prosecutor General’s Office at the time confirmed the Munich Public Prosecutor’s Office’s decision to discontinue the proceedings on grounds of proven innocence and emphasised that unlawful duplication was practically ruled out by usedSoft’s merchandise management system and the notarial certification procedure.

Topics

No Topics assigned to this article.

Article details

Published
Author
Archive
Reading time
About 3 min
Word count
418

Tags